The Bradshaw/Carter debate and the debate around 2 QBs seems to be a hot topic on the 12th Knight. What I observed this weekend from around the world of college football is that a lot of schools are using the first game as a final "toll gate" in their QB competitions.
- I'll leave Army out of this and just use examples from around D1 of how different schools use multiple QBs to be effective and show that Army isn't off base with using 2 QBs, especially early in the season or situationally.
- UGA used their veteran, Grayson Lambert early. Upon inserting the #1 QB recruit in the nation, Eason, it was clear that even as a true freshman, the moment wasn't too big for him and he is the QB of the future AND the present for the Dawgs. My prediction is Eason sees the vast majority of snaps as the season progresses.
- Auburn was a hot mess. I have NO idea what Malzahn was trying to do with 3 QBs, especially in the middle of a drive/series. If someone can explain this logic to me, I'll be happy to listen. Auburn looks like a team grasping for straws on a sinking ship.
- ND started Kizer and Zaire interchangeably in the first half, but then it became clear that Kizer will be their #1 the rest of the way. He's better.
- Bama even flirted with using 2 QBs until it became clear that Hurt (?) the true freshman is a dual threat stud who will be really hard to stop.
- IMO, Texas has the best handle on using 2 QBs. They use Swoopes and the freshman, Buechelle, situationally with Buechelle being the better passer (clearly), and Swoopes being the "18 wheeler" package QB. ND and Van Gorder had no answer for these two all night.
So, while most pundits and "analysts" (and fans) hate 2 QBs, it can be done properly especially when they have 2 completely different skill sets like at UT. In other places, I think coaches wanted to see how their kids would perform under the bright lights and now have made their decisions. In other cases (Gus Malzahn I'm looking at you), the coaches just appeared incompetent.
The other trend that has become glaringly obvious (and some fans are going to have to get used to) is how ready to go some of these true Freshmen are. Buechelle, Eason, and the kid from Bama were the stars of the weekend. What has become apparent at big time programs across the country is that the best kid plays...period. Many times the best kid is an 18 y/o straight out of HS. A lot of kids are graduating HS early and getting a semester in at college so they can attend spring practice. While we don't have this advantage, our equalizer is USMAPS.
Thoughts?